Delicious. Healthyish. Toasted. Sandwiches.

ORDER ONLINE
GET CATERING

Welcome to Sandwell! We make deliciously healthyish toasted sandwiches on our own semolina bread, baked fresh in-house daily after cold-proofing the dough for over 24 hours. Our menu features scratch-made sauces, house-whipped burrata, slow-braised turkey meatballs, hearty salads, fresh sides, and house-made beverages. We offer a modern chef-driven take on the old-school sandwich shop, all with our signature healthyish touch.

A better sandwich, done right. Bold flavor. Quality ingredients. Real value. Thoughtful service. And better-for-you.

Order today for pickup, delivery, in-store, or get catering for your next event. Three locations open — Upper West Side, Gramercy Park & SoHo — with more on the way.

As featured on NBC, ABC, Forbes, Inc Magazine, Eater, Nation’s Restaurant News, New York Business Journal & more!

View the Full Menu

  • “Literally the best sandwich shop on the UWS”

    — Kristo R

  • “The new go to spot for lunch. Incredibly flavorful but reasonably healthy sandwiches, prepared quickly and with excellent staff”

    — David R

  • "I was there yesterday with my family for the first time. BLOWN AWAY. We loved it! The sandwiches were phenomenal, and my salad was fantastic. You can absolutely tell the difference in quality- and the bread was super fresh. Can't wait to go back. Amazing addition to the UWS."

    - Rachel N

  • "I need to start by saying that I live in the UWS but work in Hudson Yards and discovered this gem last week. I purposefully come home on my lunch break to get a sandwich here… they are THAT good. Extremely well thought out sandwiches with incredible flavor. Love that you can order ahead of time. 10/10 food, service and staff."

    - Viktorija G

  • “This place is awesome. Great sandwiches, great prices, and everyone is friendly. Can’t recommend enough”

    — Drew T

  • "If you’ve ever stared into the abyss of lunchtime decision fatigue and heard the abyss whisper, “Just get a wrap,” don’t. March your indecisive self to Sandwell, where sandwiches aren’t just food—they’re salvation on semolina. I’ve been here multiple times, not because I enjoy happiness, but because even my chronic cynicism can’t argue with perfection. These people aren’t making sandwiches; they’re composing edible symphonies with the emotional depth of a Scorsese film and the structural integrity of the Hoover Dam. I bit into their lunchbox special and briefly believed in reincarnation. I was reborn as someone who understands joy. RUN, don’t walk, over there as soon as you can."

    - Jared S

  • "One of the best sandwich places in NYC in my opinion! Great food in a timely manner! Definitely would recommend and go back again and again!"

    - Nathan L

  • "Amazing sandwiches that are so fresh. The bread was probably the best sandwich bread I’ve ever had."

    - Lauren C

  • "One of the greatest sandwich shops in New York City, offering options for both meat eaters and vegans! As a meat lover and with my fiancé being a vegan, we both can attest that every sandwich here is incredibly delicious!"

    - Louis M

  • "Amazing, friendly service. Amazing, delicious sandwiches. Kings of New York, cannot recommend it more."

    - Alexander S

  • "Like, sandwiches have no right to be this good! Just so warm and well considered, great vegetarian options, and really sweet staff members. I'm happy they're busy :)"

    - Emma D

  • "Best sandwiches in this neighborhood in decades. Turkey meatball and chicken parm amazing - so I haven't tried anything else yet."

    - Nick D

  • "Best sandwich shop. Food is delicious, and the service is always great. So lucky to have them in the neighborhood!"

    - M D

  • "WOW SANDWICH SHOP OF MY DREAMS! get the upgrade for the drink, chips, and pickle! trust me :) "

    - Emily V

  • "Big fan of this place. Been going here since I moved to NYC and they always have the best sandwiches and service. Pricing and quality is so much better compared to the other sandwich options in the area. So happy to see them doing so well."

    - Yosvany B

  • "Sandwell has quickly become my go-to sandwich spot! They offer a great variety of warm and cold sandwiches, all made fresh to order. You can truly taste the quality in every bite… I also love that they call themselves Healthyish. It’s the perfect way to describe them because their sandwiches feel like a guilty pleasure, but without the guilt. They use the cleanest, best ingredients, so I can enjoy something indulgent while still knowing it’s made with care. If you’re looking for sandwiches that are delicious, fresh, and a little better for you, Sandwell is the place!"

    - Heidy H

What’s new at Sandwell? Follow us @getsandwell!

Sorry we’ve been quiet recently, we’ve been a little busy - - opening our 3rd store in SoHo!! You asked (a lot!) & we listened about coming to one of our favorite blocks in all of NYC. We’re opening next Wednesday 8/5, and we&r
Spicy chicken banh mi sandos, loading for the weekend. Grab one for lunch, the ⚽️🏆 or just because it’s always a good time to add some 🌶️ to your life. . . #healthyish #sandwell #nyceats #banhmi #spiceupyourlife
It’s never too hot for our BRAND NEW spicy special, the Pulled Turkey BBQ Sub 🔥🦃🥖🌶️☀️ Pulled slow-roasted maple turkey breast tossed with our housemade spicy chipotle bbq sauce, a light schmear of green garlic aioli on our fresh-baked semo

About Sandwell

Sandwell was founded by Andy Gottlieb in 2023 and serves chef-driven healthyish sandwiches at three New York City locations in SoHo, Gramercy Park and on the Upper West Side. Every sandwich is built on house-baked semolina bread with scratch-made sauces, house-whipped burrata, and proteins baked instead of fried. Our menu includes signature sandwiches like the Chicken Pesto Burrata, Turkey Meatball Sub, Chicken Parm, and Mushroom Cheese"steak", hearty salads, fresh sides, house-made beverages, and catering for groups of 10–300.

Sandwell is a local favorite near the Upper West Side, Central Park, American Museum of Natural History, Riverside Park, Lincoln Center, Gramercy Park, Union Square, Madison Square Park, Stuyvesant Town, Peter Cooper Village, East Village, Murray Hill, Kips Bay, Flatiron, NoMad, Stuyvesant Square, Baruch College, Empire State Building, Bellevue, NYU Langone, New York University, SoHo, Greenwich Village, the West Village, Nolita, Little Italy, Hudson Square, NoHo, Tribeca, and Washington Square Park. Popular with New Yorkers and international visitors alike — freshly made, satisfying, and rooted in New York food culture.